Amech replied with thermogravimetric data claiming 'almost zero weight loss' up to 120°C, arguing that the paste remained stable, but offered no credible explanation for the odor or the rapid structural change that Igor had observed. The company also did not reveal how the paste was made or which additives it used. When asked to provide full safety data sheets (SDS), Amech sent REACH and RoHS certificates, which turned out to be generic forms without testing annexes, dates, or formulation data, so they were insufficient for European compliance. Wallossek advised changing the silicone oil, but it does not look like Amech followed the advice.
On October 16, 2024, Igor's Lab published an article about the SGT-4 thermal paste. Instead of the usual benchmark graphics, the article listed raw laboratory data and cautioned that the material used in SGT-4 might corrode copper over time. A few weeks later, Amech responded that the smell came from a PDMS additive supplied by BYK from Germany and that the additive contained amino groups, which BYK considered safe. Meanwhile, BYK's 'safe' label referred only to CLP and GHS toxicology categories, not to compatibility with metal oxide surfaces. Thus, the product was legally compliant yet chemically destructive. Under heat and moisture, amino-functional siloxanes promote adhesion, hydrolysis, and complex formation with copper and nickel oxides. Visually, greenish or bluish deposits typical of copper salts can be observed.
Both RoHS and REACH certificates eventually sent by Amech were worthless as they provided no evidence about the actual content of SGT-4 or its corrosive behavior. RoHS confirms the absence of restricted heavy metals or brominated flame retardants, not the chemical stability of a compound. REACH asserts that substances are registered or imported under 1 ton per year, but gives no insight into additives, concentrations, or structures.
But the problem could be much bigger than just one harmful thermal paste on the market. Amech claims to be a two-person workshop in Pohang that manually produces small batches and lacks resources for proper documentation or a functioning website. However, if this were the case and Amech truly manufactured the paste itself, removing or replacing the amino additive would have been simple. To that end, Wallosek suspects that Amech just repackages premade substance from another supplier, which means that there could be other potentially dangerous thermal greases on the market.
Get Tom's Hardware's best news and in-depth reviews, straight to your inbox.
Key considerations
- Investor positioning can change fast
- Volatility remains possible near catalysts
- Macro rates and liquidity can dominate flows
Reference reading
- https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/cpus/SPONSORED_LINK_URL
- https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/cpus/producer-of-stinky-thermal-paste-that-corrodes-copper-knew-about-the-issue-since-2024#main
- https://www.tomshardware.com
- NVIDIA IGX Thor Robotics Processor Brings Real-Time Physical AI to the Industrial and Medical Edge
- Producer of stinky thermal paste that corrodes copper has known about the issue since 2024 – the paste emits acidic vapors, corrodes copper, 'glues' heatsinks t
- Razer's BlackShark V2 X gaming headset drops to less than £29 — a huge 53% saving makes them the ideal audio upgrade on a budget
- Into the Omniverse: Open World Foundation Models Generate Synthetic Worlds for Physical AI Development
- This £139 AOC gaming monitor deal is an absolute steal for 1440p gaming with a 240Hz refresh rate — 30% saving brings it to lowest-ever price
Informational only. No financial advice. Do your own research.