The EFF says the law is additionally too broad and based on uncertain science, too.
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works .
A.B. 1709 doesn't explicitly require an actual online physical ID check, but given the way it's written, companies are free to use any means they see fit to fulfill that requirement. In turn, this leads the EFF to remark that the most likely choice for networks would be invasive checks like requiring the uploading of government IDs and/or biometric checks. The Foundation says that this would concentrate even more power in social media companies' hands, with a Californian's personal ID adding to their datasets.
Not only is said data collection ripe for abuse, but it's also ripe ground for data leaks that can expose users' information to malfeasants, as proven time and again by widespread breaches that have sadly become commonplace. Events involving retail chain Target, credit-score handler Equifax, and the UnitedHealth Group all leaked out millions of vital user information, later used in criminal impersonation attacks.
The EFF also argues that A.B. 1709 wouldn't help teenagers and could do more harm than good by keeping them out of "supportive online communities," as well as "deny [them] opportunities to develop their own voices and perspectives." The letter mentions that research on whether social networks are good or bad for teens is inconclusive , and that teens could have their First Amendment rights infringed as a result.
There's also a technical angle to the complaint, as the text for A.B. 1709 includes provisions that target algorithmic feeds, autoplay, endless scroll, and push notifications for users under 16. The EFF claims the bill's wording is vague enough to be interpreted as banning key standard features of social networks. Furthermore, the bill's text seems to imply that the Attorney General could be empowered to adopt more regulations in a bid to curb those "addictive" features.
California lawmakers unanimously pass Linux exemption from age-verification law
Key considerations
- Investor positioning can change fast
- Volatility remains possible near catalysts
- Macro rates and liquidity can dominate flows
Reference reading
- https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/SPONSORED_LINK_URL
- https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/eff-asks-california-governor-to-veto-bill-that-would-require-online-age-verification-electronic-frontier-foundation-argues-bill-would-result-in-privacy-invasive-checks-and-step-on-first-amendment#main
- https://www.tomshardware.com/membership
- Hot Chips 2026: Samsung reveals a three-phase HBM roadmap that puts logic and compute inside memory — zHBM ultimately stacks DRAM directly on top of the process
- This 32GB DDR5 RAM kit is now the cheapest on sale, dropping back under $400 — 13% discount on an unflashy PNY memory kit for new gaming PC builds or upgrades
- Save $300 on this 240Hz OLED gaming laptop with an RTX 5070 Ti, now just $1,899 — Acer Predator Helios rig ships with a 24-core Intel CPU, 32GB DDR5 and a 1TB S
- Researchers easily trick Fortune-500 companies' AI agents into running arbitrary code — supply-chain attack via llms.txt guidance file illustrates how data has
- Dell's new 14-inch laptops take on the MacBook Neo in a new way — ports and colors
Informational only. No financial advice. Do your own research.